When I first heard of Serial and I found out that we were going to use it as a part of the curriculum in the classroom, I was not excited and flattered. Please do not consider that I have no taste in crime novels and mysteries. If one goes through all the books I have read, most of them are mystery books and my favorite authors are Agatha Christie and, of course, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and yet, I did not miss any movies that center around mystery and crime. Yet, I took a break and I never came back until Serial. And what do I think about this story? Do I think Adnan is innocent or is he guilty and he did kill Hae? My answer will not be a surprise to anyone.
| Hae and Adnan |
| Hae's Brother and Mother |
![]() |
| Adnan's Mother and Brother |
I think that thinking of their respective parents, justice is even more important. If Adnan did kill Hae, there is no reason there should be a serial podcast and reviving everything to make the parents feel the worst experience in their lives all over again. But, if Adnan didn't kill Hae, then, what do we do? That man has been in prison for 15 years and who will give those 15 years to him. Most importantly, that will not be fair to Hae either as she would not have want an innocent person to be in prison and convicted of her murder.
After listening to the serial podcast and poring through the transcripts, and looking from all sides of the story, I came to a conclusion. This is a simple story and it is not solved because everyone is lying. It reminds me of a mystery film called 36 china town where everyone lies because they were somehow connected to the murder.
In this serial, many people are lying to some extent. Some people lies are perceive as exaggeration, loosey-goosey with details and some people lies are utterly unjustifiable. Jay, for instance. His story's been changing ever since the first time he told the cops and yet, he get away and not even spent a day in jail. He changes his story to match with his friend Jenn. He told the cops he was afraid that Adnan is going to hurt his girlfriend Stephanie, but after interviews later, he says Adnan is threatening him with West Side hitmans and then, he told his co-worker Josh that Adnan is threatening him with people from Middle East. He do keep changing his story and what is his reason.
Well, there are many evidences to think of Jay as the real murderer such as dumping the shovels, his clothes etc from the crime day. He acted more like a criminal than Adnan did. He can also be brewing up with jealousy for the close friendship between Adnan and his girlfriend Stephanie. I am sure it is fair to say that way if the prosecutors think Adnan was jealous of Hae's new boyfriend and so on.
But, do we have enough evidences to say that Adnan killed Hae? Yes, if you think of him as a love-sick teenage guy running after his ex-girlfriend and finally killing her for emotional overload. Then, why the rest of the ex-es in the world who are in the same situation in the world are not killing each other. This doesn't make sense. There were many witnesses who says Adnan also move over after their break-up and he was normal and even flirted and made out with other girls. There is also no evidence in Hae's diary that Adnan was over-protective and possessive. My question is if the prosecutors can convict Adnan by believing Jay, why can they not believe other witnesses, Asia McClain for example. Moreover, if they can convict Adnan on thin evidences, how can they let go of Jay, Don, Mr.S, and Ronald Lee Moore, a murderer released ten days before Hae was murdered.
Interestingly, the state was not interested in this potential murderer, but stuck to Jay's timeline and his story. What I feel is that they tried to prove Adnan is the murderer regardless that there was very few tangible evidence. Here what I would like to imply is that there was no DNA evidence and any forensic or physical evidence that Adnan is guilty.
Yet, Adnan was not entirely innocent. He kept saying he didn't know where he was that evening exactly. "The Nisha Call" immediately puts Jay and Adnan in one place on that day. Cathy, Jay's friend' Jenn's close friend, remembers Jay and Adnan came to her house and that Adnan was really high on Marijuana, that he was nearly passing out and that he was acting weird. In fact, Adnan has nothing on his side except Asia McClain's word. Another flaw in this story though not really emphasized is that Hae's friend Summer claims that Hae could not be murdered in the time when the state claimed because Hae was with her. May be Adnan's lawyer M.Cristina Guiterrez realized that Asia's offer to give Adnan an alibi was worthless because Hae was still alive at that time. However, does that mean he killed Hae? Of course not.
It is, I believe, fair to say that the state did not have enough evidence to charge Adnan and to acquit Adnan. Then, how about Jay? He is also on the same boat and he was not charged. He has a story that has a lot of flaws and Adnan has no story.
A conclusion I did reach after suffering with Serial for 12 episodes whether I like it or not.
What I think is that Jay is more of a pivotal character in this story and he has more to do with the murder than any other characters. I cannot say Adnan is the murderer of Hae Min Lee and I cannot also say he has nothing to do with the murder.
Innocent until proven guilty. That is my belief in the case of Adnan Syed.


No comments:
Post a Comment